Someone is actually becoming a sort of chatterbox in his own sort of way. Our little man it seems is making up for lost time lately. He won't stop chattering. Of course his language skills are still way below the level of his peers but at least he's verbalising! One woman said in the supermarket recently "he has a funny little accent" which naturally made my mom say "oh he's French," which is her annoying, little grammy brag thing (p.s. I hate saying that...I never say it unless there is a reason like the person is French themselves --must.get.her.to.stop.this.) Besides it was not at all an accent she was noticing but his little speech problem brought on by his late talking, unless of course she's a sort of Pickering or Professor Higgins who can spot accents by regions. I think she was trying to pinpoint his bizarre way of speaking. But like I said I'm pleased for him because he's on the path to normal speech and he's communicating. Even a supermarket customer heard him chattering!
The last day of school in Mexico Little S's teachers gave me a collection of recorded cds with movies they had done of him showing him doing things like staring off in space and not paying attention. They also gave us a letter describing what problems they've noticed over the past session, --he seems to be in his little world etc etc. I smiled and thanked them, tucking the things in my bag and saying to myself "cool because I have dvd's of my son at school and no one else has that!" but knowing full well that he is fine and I would probably be canceling the appointment with the specialist we have scheduled for him in August. I'm really nervous that the appointment will stir up trouble where there is none.
It's really frightening when your son's teachers tell you they think he has a problem. This fear has enveloped me for the months ever since that parent/teacher's conference. I should have just shook my head and gone on with things but I spent way too much time Googling all the symptoms they spoke about and making myself a nervous wreck. Thank God for my friend Sara and her voice of reason. I know if I didn't have her there with her French boy and his similar speech problems our last few weeks I wouldn't have calmed down and let it all go. I have let it all go and since then, magically it's started to all go away because he is ever so slowly improving. Sarah and I talked for hours on end at the park and we both agreed that from the Mexican Directrice's perspective our boys seem mentally challenged but really much of her observations can be attributed to second and third language environmental hazards. The boys look lost because they are! It's a completely foreign environment for them. The other multi-linguals in the school that they are constantly compared to are girls and it is common knowledge that girls are linguistically stronger than boys, especially in the younger years.
I was half joking when I mentioned the word breakthough. He still has far to go before he's at the same level as a typical boy his age. I took him to story time at our local library (lie-bee) and saw firsthand what the teachers at his school meant when they talked about the staring off in the opposite direction episodes. While there was a lot of animation by the story reader and the other kids, Little S was turned completely around for most of the time. He was continually staring at the far entrance where adults were checking out books oblivious to the story and the puppets and the five other kids in the intimate story time group. This shocked me at first because I know he loves books and it was all very fun and interesting. The story reader noticed it too and kept trying to engage him more by asking him what he thought of this or that part or the book. He would turn at my prompting and answer her with a glance, follow along for maybe a minute or two and then drift back to staring at the opposite wall. Definitely unusual but maybe there is a reason who knows.
Afterwards as he played in the library's common room some bigger kids near aged six or seven commented on his funny speech and questioned it by asking their mom "what did he say?". It wasn't mocking really, just some curious observation I guess on their part but it struck me that he cannot be readily understood by his peers. Sometimes he uses an odd word or mixes languages and sometimes he just can't be understood because his speech level is at about the level of a two year old, which is not what you expect from a near four year old so I think it throws people. I was pleased though to see him blend in with these boys and not be a wallflower, but still a little concerned when he grunted this primal "grrrrr" of frustration when they stole his toy or annoyed him. I know this "grrr" thing is his upset over lack of access to proper words and I hope it won't cause him any problems at school when he starts back in September. This is where the tantrums come in.
Taking him into an English speaking environment with other kids was a great way for me to see where he needs help. I have never had this opportunity because he's always been in groups where I too spoke the native language badly and I couldn't readily tune into the communication gaps or the cultural language and eye contact. When it isn't your native language you just don't see that sort of thing without really looking closely for it. I think I'll learn a lot over these next few weeks with my observations of my little chimp Jane Goodall style. I'll be making lots of mental library notes as he plays around these groups of kids in my native tounge.
I'm not sure if he's improving very quickly but I see changes in him!
11 comments:
That was me! I messed up my comment!
And now I have to run, but I am glad you are seeing an improvement and I think you should stick with your instinct. You're his mom and you know him better than anyone else.
Agreed. My oldest son didn't say much until well after 4. He didn't need to, he was the oldest, the first grandchild on both sides, etc. and his every need was met. He was king!
Your instinct is the best guide and EVERY child develops at his or her pace.
Anon
I'm so glad to hear he's picking up a bit more these days! While I think speech therapy isn't a bad thing, as I said before I'd worry about him getting labelled when really, he's just a bit behind, which is not at all unusual with the multiple languages and moves. Sounds like he's doing great!
My cousin, who only speaks one language by the way, didn't really talk until he was 4 years old - it felt like it just came in all at once! He's really shy and to this day does not talk a lot, but it is obvious there is nothing mentally wrong with him. His mother, when asked if she had concerns that he wasn't really talking by two, insisted he was just a late talker (she is a nurse by the way) and she was right - the mother knew best. He is about to enter college now.
Compare this to your boy who has exposure to THREE languages in such a short time period. I'm not worried. My college room mate spoke three languages and told me she didn't speak till she was three - and then not all in the same language. Took her a few years to work that one out.
This is not to say that there aren't some children who know multiple languages that speak early, but I'd like to stress that each child is different.
Thanks for the supportive and friendly comments. It's been helpful to share all this because other people have a lot of stories to share and it's helpful to hear people have experienced similar things. :)
It's so hard not to worry when your kids don't speak or when they don't hit some other kind of milestone they should. I'm such a worrier! I don't have an easy time putting things out of my mind. Mothering and parenting are two totally different things. Mothering is the role I have a hard time putting aside when looking at things like this, when practical parenting should take over.
The improvement in his speaking is so nice to see & such a relief! I'm starting to realize that it's a two step forward one step back process. In the Fall when we are in France I'm sure he'll lag a little as he goes back to a bilingual household.
Thanks again for commenting.
It doesn't seem quite fair of his teachers to take movies of his behavior. I mean, I'm sure that they thought they were being helpful, but of course they're only going to capture the moments that support their stance.
I'm glad to hear that he is improving. Sophia is also a bit behind in the speech department, which I've always attributed to being exposed to two different languages. At her creche, they call her Mademoiselle Oui because she responds to every question with "Oui." I only wish it were the same in English, but then she responds to every question with "No!"
Glad to hear things are looking up - like the others said, your motherly instinct means alot.
I hesitate to suggest this because I obviously have no observations to base it on, but could the staring off into space be his way of dealing with a sensory overload? A friend's son has a sensory integration disorder and sometimes seems to be in his own world when he is really just narrowing his focus so he doesn't get overwhelmed by everything else that is coming at him. It's just a different way of taking ni the world. I feel like I am saying this in a really awkward way, but I am too tired to think any straight-er.
Erica - I did sort of encourage his teacher and the school staff when they offered to pass on these films. They often film projects and students for their records anyway so they already had some films. I was fascinated to get a sneak peek at my boy at school so I said yes of course. I haven't watched them yet though.
Lauren - I watched him do this tonight at the local library play room here in the states. A few rowdy kids came in and were chattering away in English as they overtook his little play area and from across the room I saw him suddenly go into zoned out mode and start staring at a fixed point. Then he snapped to. Afterwards when the boys had gone he mimicked their speech by repeating some of their words but in their accent and everything. It was actually kind of funny. But as for the sensory overload I thought he must have been overloaded by all the English when he did the zone-out thing with these boys. I wonder if all kids don't do this sort of thing though? I don't see enough of boys in groups to notice. I know his school thought it strange but I seem to remember one of my brothers doing this as kid.
My son is 16 months and shows signs of ASD. I've done a lot of reading on the subject because I am so worried. He is so young so it's hard to tell but we're starting to do play based (Floortime) therapy for him.
My viewpoint is that if he's "typical", he'll be okay either way, especially if we stick to Floortime. But if he ends up being on the spectrum, early intervention can really help. Therapies like Floortime are affect based and encourage social interaction and engagement. There are other methods I'll avoid since he's so young and nothing is certain.
Parroting what other people say is echolalia, a symptom of ASD. Of course, all kids go through phases.
Good luck to you!
Lynn
I too, went through this when Bubble was at school. She has a speech impediment, I have written a couple of posts about it and the maitresse said we HAD to go to the orthophonist to sort it out.
I was scared too.
We didn't go, Bubble didn't want to go, so we left it at that.
Now we are homeschooling and I think that teaching her to learn to read through the phonics method will help her pronunciation no end.
Does your oldest boy miss you when he is at school? Looking at the adults during the puppet show may indicate that he is longing for your company, or maybe that he is bored and wants to find out what the older people are doing. I actually would say that this is a very good sign - why should he be interested in what the others are interested in? His level of interest may be way above the others and this may be hard for the teachers to comprehend. They may see him as withdrawn, but he maybe just waiting for something to come along that will spark his interest.
Also, I would say that the teachers at school in France have your son's best interest at heart and they are identifying the problem because they have to refer him to a professional because there is none or little special needs training in schools. But once you are in the special needs system at school you will get a very heavy load of extra work to do with you son, plus homework, which can be a lot when he gets older. Perhaps the thing he most needs right now is *less* formal work, more relaxed play and less pressure to achieve, that may also be the root cause of the problem. Even at this tender age, there is a huge pressure for children to fit in and be accepted as *normal*, something he may be struggling with at the moment.
In my humble opinion I think he needs to be at home with you!!!!
I am not just saying this because I home school, but because from what I have read, children who start to show these kind of signs, need the stable environment of their parents more than other children do.
He will then be given a chance to thrive in a stress free environment, perhaps you could consider it for a couple of years and then put him back in school?
You are in a great position because he already has french friends whom you can keep in contact with so that he may keep up with french at his own level. You may find that playing out of the school environment with these kids may be all he needs to get more involved. Play time away from school is 100% more constructive and nurturing than the push and shove of the playground.
Have you ever considered it?
He would be able to get involved and learn things that he is *totally* interested in and he may far exceed your idea of what he is capable of at the moment.
As for the little one, Squeak is now two and a half but only started talking two months ago, she had a kind of babbling language before then. All children start when they are ready. I believe that she has been listening and absorbing stuff all this time and she will not have any problems catching up.
hope this helps!
Lune x
Post a Comment