Monday, January 18, 2010

Education privée

I have lots of pictures to share of Little S's room and all the hard work I've put into the paint and woodwork. He still hasn't fully moved back in but he will soon, just as soon asI paint a few pieces of furniture and put together his new bookshelf.

Meanwhile on top of all of this renovating business and cleansing the house I'm starting to look around at private schools for Little S. The public school is okay and he loves his class, but even S's teacher admitted to us that a child like him needs more individual attention than the public system can offer him. It's fine now while he's still in kindergarten but next year when he starts elementary school she's told us he'll likely fall behind unless he gets help. So I'm just sort of window shopping in the private sector, but in all likelihood he'll start CP next year in the public school with the rest of his friends and we'll see how it goes.

On Saturday the Montessori school, practically in our backyard, had an open house in the morning and I visited just for the heck of it. I figured if I start work in the Fall we can afford it and even though it would be nearly half my measely salary it would be worth it. I think I'd probably built this school up into something else, probably because Little S's school in Mexico was so chic and gorgeous and the directrice was a dynamic pistol really passionate about her school. She sold Montessori like street vendors in Mexico sell rare trinkets. In fifteen minutes we were convinced there was no way he couldn't go there! We enrolled him right away after the first meeting.

Saturday was an entirely different story. The school was freezing, so cold I had to keep my winter hat and coat on. There was no coffee or snacks and in my mind I'd already said to myself "I can't drink too much coffee or I'll have to pee! oh well at least I can check out the toilets when I pee" But there was no coffee or water or anything. Okay maybe not entirely necessary but an important welcome gesture if you ask me. I was the last to walk in and there were about a dozen cold parents sitting in a circle, huddled around a table of materials. They were staring at their shoes, clearing their throats and listening to a low-talking director drone on and on and ON about the problems with public schools. Every once in a while he'd pick up a very worn out Montessori cube and explain it to the parents in minute detail, but who could hear because he was mumbling so much? And then for no reason he'd start talking about something completely different. The plants in the schoool were all dead or in the process of dying a slow death, frozen no doubt and the desks were all worn with broken or missing parts. Most of the furniture was mismatched, cheap plastic and the walls were plastered in tattered, half hung posters from years gone by. There was a huge, nasty television in every room with video tapes stacked nearby (groan) and in one room the mess was so bad that there was an overflowing garbage sac on the floor, papers spilling out, that we actually had to daintily step around to go into the classrom. "Voila c'est notre petit école!" the director kept saying sticking his chest out. The whole school was like this though, "a petit mess".

It was one of those moments in my life where I said "I can do better than this." You know those moments where you see someone doing something you love and doing it badly. I said to myself "I'd love to have this school. I could do this so much with it." I left the school with some badly photocopied papers (first impressions people) and a big question mark over my head. All the other parents stayed behind to ask more questions, apparently interested (bigger question mark), but I was eager to leave.

a typical Montessori classroom found randomly on the internet--lots of light, plants, wood furniture, clean...and most likely WARM. This is what I'd had built up in my head but it wasn't at all like this...

Later I told my neighbor about it. She has her son in a private school nearby and she said "oh yeah they're all like that. Dimi's school too." It didn't seem to bother her. I think for the amount of money you pay they could at least clean and organize the schools. For me the learning environment should be really nice. I always reorganized the classrooms I worked in, took old things off the walls and tried to clean up. It motivated ME as a teacher. In Montessori one of the main principles is that the school is beautiful, --they're often filled with plants and usually have nice, wood furniture to help the kids learn to love and respect the learning environment. The kids in a Montessori school even help raise and care for the plants and I believe they clean the help clean the classroom too. It certainly wasn't the case in this school. All I could think of was poor Little S if he had to go here. He'd end up like those plants!

I'm curious to see some of the other private schools in the area. I wonder if they're all such a mess like my neighbor says. If that's the case then no thanks. I'd rather home school.

12 comments:

Anonymous said...

Just out of curiosity have you looked into homeschooling in France? I was under the impression that it was really difficult to do... I have no idea what we will do in the future, but the idea is kind of intriguing. I would love to find a small private school to teach in and send my girl there for school as well. It would be the perfect situation I think!

TEFL Ninja said...

I had the same shock when we looked into private here. and the teaching reflected the environment. Shabby, out of date and uninspired.

It was like paying through the nose for much the same as you get in the public system.

The only great school I saw was run by my old director of studies after she got fed up of paying tonnes of money for a crappy education for her daughter and decided to show them how it's done, but Milan was too far away to commute to everyday for a little kid so...home educate it had to be.

TEFL Ninja said...

Ashley

Try ths link for some info of Home ed in france, always worth deeper investigation as when things look nice and easy a bit of scratching under the surface throws up a few road bumps but it looks like a good place to start.

http://www.frenchentree.com/fe-education/DisplayArticle.asp?ID=21708

Jennifer said...

Jack's school is not the prettiest. Schools are shabby here too. The public schools make my stomach turn. The private schools aren't quite so bad (in general) but they are old.

His school repaints the rooms as often as they can, so that helps. And it is very, very clean (Italians are obsessed with hygiene, so the private schools are PRISTINE.) But that picture you posted is so lovely. Ah. In my dreams! I went to Montessori school for preschool and I remember it being so nice. But that was in the States.

You probably would do a very good job with him. Homeschooling is not for me, but lots of people do it and it works well for them.

Nicole said...

In our neighborhood, I was pretty shocked by how run down the public school looked, but the Catholic school that Ella is going to next year is amazing. This particular school is a parish school so the church owns the building and the teachers are sous contract, paid by the government (if I understand it right). That means that our tuition goes towards supplies and equipment but in a Montessori, your tuition needs to pay for building, teachers, AND equipment/supplies. Saying that, the Montessori in the 5th is really nice although it costs over 4000 euros for the year.
I do wonder about the public school teacher's advice. Under the new system, all schools are supposed to have private tuition available to students who fall behind their class. What I understood is that the assistants who do this job are automatically scheduled for a certain number of hours per school or class so they are available if/when they are needed. Unless there are lots of students in your school that need help, you should be able to get just as much help (if not more) thanb in a private school.

christine said...

Ashley - I have looked into it but I'm a bit overwhelmed with the idea of teaching (helping him) with French grammar and maths. It's probably just me afraid of bucking the system and maybe it could work. We've talked about it a lot and Seb who was originally against it is coming around but I'm a little afraid of not having the patience for it.

sarah - yes I'm starting to see this!

Jennifer - It's the other way around here. His public school has higher standards and it's much nicer. It's actually pretty clean and organzied and the teachers are wonderful. His classes are just too big. He needs smaller classes.

Nicole - This school costs nearly what the Montessori in the 5th costs and they're full! As for the assistants in the public system he does have an AVS in his class this year which he uses a lot but the AVS is really there for the two kids in his class who are mentally handicapped. In her extra time she helps S and a few other kids who fall behind. S will have to be diagnosed with something in order to have an AVS in his class next year. His teacher says that without the AVS he'd be really lost and she wonders how he'll do next year without one in the class (the two AVS students will be gone). Anyway I think that's what you were talking about, right?

Anonymous said...

Yea that was kind of my thoughts too. Eek, the French and Math! But I guess if you really wanted too you could have a tutor or something like that... Thanks for the link Sarah. I have never heard of students being homeschooled in France so the whole thing really intrigues me. Well I have heard of students 'par correspondance' that live in the far countryside where they would either have to stay at school (sleep there and everything) during the week and only come home on weekends!

I don't know if I would have the patience either but I find it tempting. We are way far off from that though, I just have to wait and see how things go!

TEFL Ninja said...

Ashley

There is always this for the maths, it has taken a huge chunk of work off my hands

http://www.whizz.com/

As for the French, to be honest if I didn't have a live human resource in the form of my Italian husband wandering around the house I'd be a bit stuck on that front.

I don't think it is the patience that is the sticking point for me, despite not having a lot, it is the time...and the space for mummy to just be. But we are only in month three so that might be adjustment niggles (I hope)

Personally I wouldn't have done it if he hadn't been so unhappy and the teaching so poor, I'd have left him in shcool and just tried to keep him up in the English on the side.

Pauline said...

School in France used to be open on Saturday mornings, now that this is no longer the case the teachers use these hours of work to help out the children who are falling behind. I think that this is the « aide individuelle » that Nicole is talking about

In my sons school this was usually done for 30/45 minute session during the lunch hour ( children have 2 hours break between 11h30 – 13h30) in very small group of 4-6 children a couple of times a week. The subjets in his school were the basics French - Maths and they also did a theatre group for the children who were lacking in confidence/bad communication skills

Nicole said...

Thanks Pauline, that is what I meant.

hexe said...

You know that I too have struggled with the public.private education issue here. The grim reality was that even in nice looking private school, the education is mediocre and I have to fill the holes. The only advice I can give you is to be around enough to see where the school is lacking so you can make up the difference.

Anonymous said...

We decided to homeschool here in Switzerland, and despite any initial doubts...it was the best decision we've ever made! Forget any worries about math. French would be easy to organize. Good luck on your search!
-Calynde